
Juventus thought they had scored a late winner against Rennes, but Lucumí’s potential winning goal was ruled out following a VAR review. The incident in the 88th minute led to a debate over offside: did the defender’s touch amount to a deliberate play, or was it a deflection that left the original offside offence intact? The Europa League match ended 2-2.
What happened in the penalty area?
Jhon Lucumí was in an offside position when a Juventus teammate played the ball into the danger area. The ball subsequently touched a Rennes defender and reached Lucumí, who finished. Referee Morten Krogh reviewed the incident at the pitchside monitor and disallowed the goal. The central question was the type of intervening touch made by the French side’s defender.
Why the VAR decision can be defended
Sky Sport presenter Mario Giunta explained one plausible interpretation: the referee saw a deflection by the Rennes defender because the ball arrived suddenly and there may have been a lack of full body control. Under that reading, the defender did not deliberately play the ball, so Lucumí’s earlier offside position still mattered.
The guidelines consider the distance the ball travels, its speed, whether the defender can see it coming and whether there is time to coordinate a movement. A distinction is drawn between a deliberate play and an accidental deflection. A touch by an opponent does not automatically reset offside.
Why the decision is disputed
Other observers interpreted the same action differently. La Gazzetta dello Sport reported that Mayenda touched the ball while trying to clear it and treated that touch as a deliberate play. Under that interpretation, Lucumí could have legally collected the ball and the goal should have stood. A separate explanation argued that the close-range intervention was instinctive.
The dispute is therefore not whether Lucumí was initially offside but whether the defender’s subsequent action changed the phase of play. The match officials ruled that it did not, and the 2-2 result remained.
Sources: TuttoJuve, Benedetta Demichelis, Mario Giunta/Sky Sport; Fanpage, Michele Mazzeo; La Gazzetta dello Sport, Vincenzo Di Schiavi.
Read also: Juventus 2-2 Rennes: Woltemade rescues point as VAR denies Lucumí winner · Juventus confirm injuries to Çelik and Nico González after Rennes
Source: TuttoJuve (relacja z Sky Sport) / Fanpage / La Gazzetta dello Sport